Introduction

Choosing between Quartz and Granite countertops can be challenging. Both materials offer exceptional beauty and durability, but they differ in various aspects that can significantly impact your decision. This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about Quartz vs Granite, making it easier to select the ideal countertop for your home.

 

Understanding the Basics

What is Quartz?
Quartz is an engineered stone made from crushed natural quartz crystals combined with resin binders and pigments. The result is a durable, non-porous surface available in a wide range of colors and patterns. Because it is manufactured, Quartz can mimic the look of natural stone or have a uniform, contemporary appearance.

What is Granite?
Granite is a natural stone quarried from the earth, cut into slabs, and polished for use as a countertop material. Each slab of Granite is one-of-a-kind, featuring unique patterns, colors, and veining formed over millions of years. Granite’s natural appeal and durability make it a popular choice for homeowners.

Key Differences at a Glance

Feature Quartz Granite
Composition 90-95% Crushed Quartz + Resin 100% Natural Stone
Porosity Non-porous Porous (Usually Requires Sealing)†
Appearance Consistent, Customizable Natural, Unique Patterns
Maintenance Low Maintenance Moderate Maintenance
Durability Scratch and Stain Resistant Highly Durable, Heat Resistant

 

Appearance and Aesthetics

The aesthetics of your countertop play a significant role in defining the overall style and atmosphere of your kitchen. Both Quartz and Granite offer distinctive looks and suit different preferences and design visions. Let’s explore how these materials complement various kitchen styles, their application settings, limitations, and current trends.

Quartz: Consistency and Customization

  • Modern and Contemporary Kitchens: With its uniform patterns and vibrant color options, Quartz is a perfect fit for modern, minimalist, or industrial kitchens. The sleek, polished look of Quartz enhances a clean, streamlined aesthetic.
  • Bold Color Choices: Since Quartz is engineered, it’s available in shades ranging from pure white and soft grays to striking blacks and jewel tones. This opens up bold design opportunities, especially in ultra-modern homes.
  • Marble-Like Designs: Quartz manufacturers can create realistic marble imitations without the upkeep challenges of natural stone, making it a suitable choice for those seeking a luxurious yet low-maintenance kitchen.
  • Small and Open-Concept Spaces: Lighter Quartz designs with subtle veining can brighten up compact kitchens, creating an illusion of spaciousness.


Granite: Natural Beauty and Character

  • Traditional and Rustic Kitchens: The earthy tones, rich veining, and natural variations of Granite add warmth and authenticity to traditional or farmhouse-style kitchens. Each slab tells a story of nature’s artistry.
  • Statement Countertops: Granite slabs often become the focal point in kitchen designs, especially when selecting rare or exotic stones.
  • Large Kitchens and Islands: In spacious kitchens, Granite’s bold patterns can complement oversized islands or expansive countertops, adding grandeur to the space.
  • Outdoor Kitchens: Due to its resilience to natural elements, Granite is an ideal choice for outdoor kitchen countertops.


Application Scenarios and Limitations

  • Quartz:
    • Best for indoor use as UV exposure can cause discoloration.
    • Ideal for busy households due to its stain-resistant nature.
    • Not recommended near intense heat sources like fireplaces.
  • Granite:
    • Suitable for both indoor and outdoor applications.
    • Might not be ideal for homeowners seeking a uniform, contemporary look.


Current Trends in Quartz and Granite Aesthetics

  • Quartz Trends:
    • Matte and honed finishes are gaining popularity, offering a softer, more natural look.
    • Veined Quartz with marble-like designs remains a top choice for luxurious kitchens.
    • Waterfall countertops, where the Quartz extends vertically down the sides, create a striking modern statement.
  • Granite Trends:
    • Dark Granite with bold veining complements dramatic, moody kitchen designs.
    • Leathered finishes, offering a textured matte look, are a stylish choice for rustic or industrial settings.
    • Contrasting Granite islands paired with lighter cabinetry add visual interest.


Choosing Based on Personal Style:

  • Love bold statement pieces? Opt for Granite.
  • Prefer a sleek, elegant look? Quartz might be the better choice.
  • Want low-maintenance luxury? Consider Quartz for hassle-free upkeep.
  • Desire a timeless, natural element? Granite will provide authentic beauty.

By carefully considering your kitchen’s design, lighting, and your lifestyle preferences, you’ll find the material that perfectly suits your needs.

 

Durability and Maintenance

When it comes to durability and resistance to common kitchen challenges, both Quartz and Granite offer impressive qualities. However, they perform differently in specific scenarios. Let’s break down their resistance to heat, scratches, stains, chemicals, and impacts — along with practical tips to keep your countertops in top shape.


Heat Resistance

  • Quartz: Quartz is not naturally heat-resistant due to the resin binders used in its construction. Prolonged exposure to high temperatures, typically above 150°F (65°C), can discolor or damage the surface. Always use trivets or hot pads under hot cookware to prevent heat damage.
  • Granite: Granite is inherently heat-resistant as a natural stone formed under high temperatures. It can withstand hot pans and pots better than Quartz. However, extreme temperature shifts can cause cracking, so using heat protectors is still recommended.

Tip: Never place a slow cooker or air fryer directly on a Quartz countertop. For Granite, although it can tolerate heat, consider using coasters to preserve its finish.


Scratch Resistance

  • Quartz: Quartz is highly scratch-resistant, often ranking around 7 on the Mohs hardness scale. However, its resin can be damaged by sharp knives, so using cutting boards is advisable.
  • Granite: Granite is extremely durable, typically ranking between 6-7 on the Mohs scale. While it can withstand knife use better than Quartz, repeated cutting directly on its surface can dull knives and create minor scratches.

Tip: Use a designated cutting board for meal prep on both materials to prevent scratches.


Stain Resistance

  • Quartz: Being non-porous, Quartz resists stains from common substances like coffee, wine, and oil. Cleanup is easy with warm water and mild detergent.
  • Granite: Traditionally required sealing to prevent staining. However, Legacy Marble & Granite exclusively uses resin-sealed granite slabs and applies a lifetime sealer during fabrication, eliminating this concern for most homeowners.

Tip: For both surfaces, wipe up spills immediately to prevent staining. Avoid using abrasive pads or harsh chemicals.

Chemical Resistance

  • Quartz: Quartz countertops are resistant to household chemicals like vinegar and lemon juice. However, harsh cleaners with bleach or ammonia can break down the resin and dull the surface.
  • Granite: Granite can tolerate acidic substances better than Quartz, but it’s still advisable to avoid prolonged exposure to vinegar, citrus, or strong cleaners.

Tip: Use pH-neutral stone cleaners for both materials to maintain their finish and longevity.

Impact Resistance

  • Quartz: Quartz has a slightly higher flexibility compared to Granite, making it more resistant to chipping or cracking upon impact. However, heavy blows on edges can still cause damage.
  • Granite: While robust, Granite can chip or crack under extreme impact, particularly around vulnerable edges.

Tip: Avoid dropping heavy objects on both Quartz and Granite, especially near sink edges or corners. Install rounded edges for better impact resistance.

Maintenance Recap:

  • Quartz: Clean with mild soap and water, avoid high heat and harsh chemicals, and use cutting boards and trivets.
  • Granite: Clean with stone-safe cleaners, seal regularly, and protect from heat and impacts.

 

Quartz vs Granite: Detailed Look at Cost Factors

When it comes to choosing between Quartz and Granite countertops, understanding the cost implications is essential. This section provides a detailed analysis of the key factors impacting project costs and offers practical strategies to help homeowners in Ohio minimize expenses.

Factors Influencing Countertop Costs

  1. Material Quality and Grade:
    • Quartz: Premium Quartz with intricate veining and patterns tends to be more expensive. Simple, solid-colored Quartz is generally more affordable.
    • Granite: Rare granite slabs with unique colors or bold patterns can drive up costs, while common shades like black, white, and gray are more budget-friendly.
  2. Slab Thickness:
    • Countertops are typically available in 2 cm and 3 cm thicknesses. Thicker slabs are more durable and luxurious but also pricier.
  3. Fabrication and Installation:
    • Intricate edge profiles, cutouts for sinks, and customized shapes increase labor and fabrication expenses.
  4. Sealing and Maintenance:
    • Granite traditionally required regular sealing, but Legacy Marble & Granite uses resin-treated slabs and applies a lifetime sealer, removing this ongoing cost for most customers.
  5. Transportation and Location:
    • Locally available materials are often more affordable than imported granite slabs. Homeowners in Ohio might find better pricing on regional stones.


Cost-Saving Tips and Strategies

  1. Choose Prefabricated Slabs: Some suppliers offer prefabricated Quartz or Granite slabs with standard dimensions, which can reduce fabrication costs.
  2. Opt for Simpler Edge Designs: Standard edge profiles like eased or beveled edges are more cost-effective than intricate designs.
  3. Mix and Match: Consider using a premium stone for the island countertop while opting for a more affordable material for surrounding surfaces.
  4. Explore Remnants: Small countertop spaces, like bathrooms, may benefit from leftover slab remnants available at discounted rates.
  5. Get Multiple Quotes: Compare quotes from different suppliers and installers to ensure you’re receiving the best deal.


Final Thoughts on Cost Considerations

When comparing Quartz and Granite, both materials offer stunning aesthetics and lasting durability. Quartz often provides a more predictable pricing structure, while Granite’s cost fluctuates based on rarity and demand. 

If you’re looking for personalized guidance or a detailed quote, contact Legacy Marble & Granite for a free consultation. Our experts can help you determine the best countertop option for your style, budget, and functional needs.

 

Environmental Impact and Sustainability

For environmentally conscious homeowners, understanding the sustainability of their countertop materials is crucial. Both Quartz and Granite have environmental impacts, but the extent varies depending on factors like sourcing, production, transportation, and longevity.

Material Sourcing and Extraction

  • Quartz: As an engineered product, Quartz countertops use a combination of natural quartz and resin. While quartz is abundant and accessible, the resin component (often made from petroleum-based products) contributes to its carbon footprint.
  • Granite: Granite is extracted from quarries, a process that can significantly alter landscapes and ecosystems. However, because it is entirely natural, it requires no additional chemical binders.

Tip: Opt for Quartz brands that use recycled materials and environmentally friendly resins or source locally quarried Granite to reduce emissions.


Energy Consumption and Carbon Footprint

  • Quartz: The manufacturing process of Quartz involves high energy consumption due to the heating, mixing, and binding processes. However, advancements in technology are making some manufacturers more energy-efficient.
  • Granite: Granite has a lower carbon footprint if sourced locally, but imported Granite slabs may result in higher emissions from transportation.

Resource: Read about sustainable stone sourcing.

 

Durability and Longevity

  • Both materials are extremely durable, reducing the need for frequent replacements. Longer-lasting countertops mean fewer resources are consumed over time.
  • Quartz’s non-porous nature makes it more stain-resistant and easier to maintain, reducing the need for harsh cleaning chemicals.

Tip: Choose a timeless design that won’t go out of style to extend the functional life of your countertops.

 

Recyclability and End-of-Life Impact

  • Quartz: Due to the resin content, Quartz countertops are not recyclable. Disposal typically results in landfill waste.
  • Granite: Natural Granite can often be recycled or repurposed for other construction projects or landscaping.

Resource: Learn more about recycling natural stone.

 

Eco-Friendly Alternatives and Certifications

  • Look for Quartz brands that offer Greenguard Gold Certification or NSF Certification for low chemical emissions.
  • Some Granite suppliers now follow sustainable quarrying practices certified by the Natural Stone Sustainability Standard.

Resource: Explore certified sustainable stone suppliers.

 

Conclusion: Choosing the Sustainable Option

When making a decision based on environmental impact, consider factors like longevity, sourcing location, and manufacturing practices. Locally quarried Granite or Quartz brands using recycled content can significantly reduce your carbon footprint. For personalized recommendations and insights on eco-friendly countertop options, contact Legacy Marble & Granite for expert guidance.

 

Common Myths and Misconceptions About Quartz and Granite

When considering Quartz or Granite countertops, misinformation can cloud your decision. Let’s break down some of the most common myths and provide clear, factual insights to help you make an informed choice.

Myth 1: Quartz is Completely Natural

Reality: Quartz countertops are engineered using around 90-95% natural quartz crystals combined with resins, polymers, and pigments. While the primary material is natural, the manufacturing process introduces synthetic components that enhance durability and appearance.

Why the Myth Exists: Since Quartz mimics the look of natural stone, many assume it is a purely natural product.

When It Might Matter: If you prioritize completely natural materials for eco-friendly construction, Granite would be the more appropriate choice.

 

Myth 2: Granite Requires Excessive Maintenance

Reality: While Granite does require periodic sealing to maintain its non-porous properties, modern sealers can last for years with minimal upkeep. Routine cleaning with mild soap and water is usually sufficient. 

At Legacy Marble & Granite, we use only resin-sealed slabs and apply a lifetime sealer, making granite a low-maintenance choice that rivals quartz.

 

Why the Myth Exists: Historically, sealing products had a short lifespan, creating the perception of high maintenance.

Modern Truth: Legacy’s process virtually eliminates the need for homeowners to ever reseal their granite countertops.

Resource: Learn more about Granite maintenance tips.

 

Myth 3: Quartz Cannot Withstand Heat

Reality: While Quartz is heat-resistant to a degree, excessive exposure to direct heat from pots and pans can damage the resin binders. Using trivets or hot pads is recommended.

Why the Myth Exists: Compared to Granite, which is naturally more heat-tolerant, Quartz’s resin content makes it more vulnerable to extreme temperatures.

Solution: If you frequently cook with high heat, consider Granite for areas near stoves and ovens.

 

Myth 4: Granite Is Prone to Staining

Reality: Granite is naturally porous, but with proper sealing, it becomes highly resistant to stains. Promptly wiping up spills, especially from acidic substances, will prevent long-term staining.

Why the Myth Exists: Unsealed or improperly sealed Granite can absorb liquids, leading to stains.

Pro Tip: Test your Granite by dropping a few water droplets on its surface. If the water beads up, your seal is intact. If it soaks in, resealing may be needed.

 

Myth 5: Quartz Is Always More Expensive Than Granite

Reality: Pricing for both materials can vary widely depending on factors like origin, quality, and design. While Quartz can sometimes be more expensive due to intricate designs, high-end Granite slabs can also come with a hefty price tag.

Why the Myth Exists: Engineered Quartz often comes with a predictable price per square foot, while Granite pricing fluctuates based on availability and rarity.

Fact Check: For a mid-range kitchen remodel, both Quartz and Granite countertops can fall within the $50-$150 per square foot range.

 

Myth 6: Quartz Looks Artificial Compared to Granite

Reality: Modern Quartz manufacturers offer designs that closely resemble natural stone, complete with veining and color variations. Some premium Quartz brands provide slabs that are nearly indistinguishable from Granite or Marble.

Why the Myth Exists: Earlier Quartz designs had a more uniform appearance, which lacked the organic appeal of natural stone.

Consideration: If you prefer natural imperfections and uniqueness, Granite remains a top choice.

 

Myth 7: Granite Countertops Emit Harmful Radiation

Reality: While Granite contains trace amounts of naturally occurring radioactive elements like uranium, the levels are extremely low and pose no health risk. Regulatory agencies, including the EPA, confirm that Granite countertops are safe for homes.

Why the Myth Exists: Fear-mongering headlines have exaggerated concerns about radiation from natural stone.

Further Reading: Visit the EPA’s official statement on Granite safety for more information.

 

Myth 8: Quartz and Granite Are Only for Kitchens

Reality: Both materials are incredibly versatile and can be used in bathrooms, fireplaces, outdoor kitchens, and even as flooring or wall cladding.

Why the Myth Exists: Countertops are the most common application, leading to the misconception that Quartz and Granite are unsuitable for other spaces.

Design Tip: Consider using Quartz for sleek, modern bathroom vanities or Granite for rustic outdoor BBQ stations.

 

Myth 9: Quartz Is Maintenance-Free

Reality: While Quartz is low-maintenance compared to Granite, it still requires regular cleaning to prevent staining and buildup. Abrasive cleaners can damage its surface, so gentle cleaning is recommended.

Why the Myth Exists: The non-porous nature of Quartz leads people to believe it’s entirely maintenance-free.

Maintenance Guide: Clean Quartz surfaces with a mixture of mild soap and water, and avoid using harsh chemicals.


Understanding the truth behind these common myths can empower you to make a confident choice between Quartz and Granite countertops. If you’d like personalized advice or further clarification, reach out to Legacy Marble & Granite for a free consultation.

 

Popular Quartz and Granite Varieties

To help you visualize the possibilities, we’ve compiled a list of the most popular Quartz and Granite varieties, along with their price ranges and notable features. On our website, you can explore images of each type to see how they might complement your design vision.

 

Popular Quartz Varieties

  1. Calacatta Quartz
    • Features: Luxurious white background with bold gray veining, often mimicking the appearance of Calacatta Marble.
    • Best For: Modern, minimalist, or classic kitchens.
    • Colors Available: White with gray or gold veining.
  2. Carrara Quartz
    • Features: Subtle gray veining on a white base, resembling Carrara Marble.
    • Best For: Traditional and contemporary settings.
    • Colors Available: White with soft gray patterns.
  3. Statuario Quartz
    • Features: Striking veins with a dramatic effect, ideal for making a bold statement.
    • Best For: High-end luxury kitchens and bathrooms.
    • Colors Available: White with dark gray veining.
  4. Sparkling White Quartz
    • Features: A clean, bright white surface embedded with mirror-like flecks.
    • Best For: Contemporary kitchens and minimalist interiors.
    • Colors Available: White with sparkling accents.
  5. Concrete Quartz
    • Features: Industrial-style, matte finish with a subtle concrete-like texture.
    • Best For: Urban lofts and industrial-style kitchens.
    • Colors Available: Gray, black, or taupe.
  6. Galaxy Black Quartz
    • Features: Deep black base with shimmering metallic flecks.
    • Best For: Modern and luxurious spaces.
    • Colors Available: Black with silver or gold specks.

 

Popular Granite Varieties

  1. Black Galaxy Granite
    • Features: Deep black surface with golden or silver specks.
    • Best For: Modern kitchens and bathrooms.
    • Colors Available: Black with gold or silver flecks.
  2. White Ice Granite
    • Features: Crisp white background with shades of blue and gray veining.
    • Best For: Coastal and contemporary interiors.
    • Colors Available: White with blue-gray veins.
  3. Ubatuba Granite
    • Features: Dark green with flecks of gold, brown, and black.
    • Best For: Traditional and rustic designs.
    • Colors Available: Deep green with gold and black patterns.
  4. Blue Pearl Granite
    • Features: Shimmering blue with silver and gray mineral deposits.
    • Best For: Bold and luxurious spaces.
    • Colors Available: Dark blue with silver highlights.
  5. Giallo Ornamental Granite
    • Features: Creamy beige with brown and gray specks.
    • Best For: Warm, classic interiors.
    • Colors Available: Beige, gold, or light brown.
  6. Colonial White Granite
    • Features: Soft white base with hints of gray and black specks.
    • Best For: Farmhouse and traditional kitchens.
    • Colors Available: White with gray and black patterns.
  7. Absolute Black Granite
    • Features: Pure black, polished, or honed for a sleek appearance.
    • Best For: Modern, minimalist, and industrial-style spaces.
    • Colors Available: Solid black.

Explore Further

Visit our gallery to see detailed images of these Quartz and Granite varieties in real-life applications. If you need personalized recommendations or want to explore more options, contact our experts at Legacy Marble & Granite for a free consultation.

 

Conclusion and Next Steps

Deciding between Quartz and Granite countertops ultimately comes down to your priorities and preferences. If you value durability, natural beauty, and the uniqueness of every slab, Granite may be the ideal choice. On the other hand, if you prefer low-maintenance, customizable designs with excellent stain resistance, Quartz could be your best option.

At Legacy Marble & Granite, we are passionate about helping homeowners in Findlay, Bowling Green, Lima, Toledo, and the surrounding areas of Ohio make informed decisions that enhance their spaces. With years of experience in the countertop industry, we offer personalized guidance, extensive material selections, and expert installation services.

We invite you to visit our showroom to explore the beauty and variety of Quartz and Granite countertops firsthand. Our knowledgeable team will assist you in comparing different options, understanding pricing, and selecting the perfect material to suit your style and needs. Whether you’re planning a kitchen remodel, bathroom upgrade, or new construction project, we are committed to bringing your vision to life.

For personalized assistance or to schedule a free consultation, contact Legacy Marble & Granite today. Let us help you navigate your Quartz vs Granite decision with confidence. Visit our showroom today or call 419-664-5026 for expert advice. Your dream countertops are just a consultation away — we can’t wait to work with you!